Energy Payments for Economic Activation of Demand Response Resources

Energy payments (or utilization payments) for the economic dispatch of demand response (DR) resources has been an ongoing topic of discussion at the Demand Response Working Group (DRWG).  Stakeholder interest in energy payments was renewed as a result of proposed market rule amendments to enable off-contract, non-regulated dispatchable generators to participate in the capacity auction along with dispatchable loads and hourly demand response resources.

To date, DRWG has been the forum for discussions with stakeholders on energy payments for DR resources – for both economic dispatch and out-of-market activations.  However, given that energy payments for economic dispatch of DR resources is a complex issue and would be a substantive change to Ontario’s energy market, the IESO has determined that a broader stakeholder engagement is needed to advise on this issue.  Energy payments for out of market activations will continue to be discussed through DRWG with the intent to implement the proposal by the December 2019 capacity auction.

Through this engagement, the IESO will seek feedback from stakeholders on:

  • The inputs and outputs of the research and analysis required to determine whether there is a net benefit to electricity ratepayers if DR resources are compensated with energy payments for economic activations. The IESO will commission a third party consultant to support the research and analysis.
  • The IESO’s decision and rationale on whether demand response resources will be compensated with energy payments for economic activations

Additional details on the IESO’s plans to engage with stakeholders can be found in the engagement plan (updated October 10, 2019). All comments and enquiries on this engagement can be directed to engagement@ieso.ca.

Anticipated timing for this engagement is presented below.


Documents referenced on this page, but not posted, can be obtained by contacting engagement@ieso.ca with a link to the web page that lists the document and advise whether it needs to be provided in an accessible format. Please allow a minimum of one business day for a response.


Schedule of Activities

Date

Activities

Expected Actions

December 10, 2020

Final Engagement Summary Report

 

September 17, 2020

Stakeholder feedback on materials presented at August 26th webinar.

 

August 26, 2020

Webinar

The IESO will review and provide a response to stakeholder feedback received following the last webinar on May 21 and provide further details and proposed next steps on the options to address DR shut-down costs.

Recorded Presentation

This webinar is being presented during the IESO's August stakeholder engagement meetings. See agenda for more information.

Registration list

June 11, 2020

Stakeholder feedback on materials presented at May 21st webinar.

 

May 21, 2020

Webinar

This session will close out the initial scope with the final Brattle study results, and begin discussing cost-recovery for shut-down costs related to Demand Response activations.

Recorded Presentation

This webinar is being presented during the IESO's May stakeholder engagement meetings. See agenda for more information

April 15, 2020

Update on Energy Payments for Economic Activation of DR Resources Stakeholder Engagement

 

March 6, 2020

Stakeholder feedback on materials presented at February 13th meeting

  • Ryerson Centre for Urban Energy
 

February 13, 2020

Agenda

Meeting Notes

 

Meeting

 

January 24, 2020

  • OEB Decision in AMPCO Motion on TCA Market Rules
 

Documents prior to 2020

Documents are available upon request. Email engagement@ieso.ca with specific instructions and advise if an accessible format is needed.

 

December 20, 2019

Stakeholder feedback on materials presented at December 11th meeting

  • AMPCO
  • Centre for Urban Energy at Ryerson University
  • Rodan Energy Solutions
 

December 11, 2019

Agenda

Webinar

 

November 2019

Present final study scope and study plan

 

October 25, 2019

 

Stakeholder feedback on materials presented at October 10th meeting

  • AEMA
  • AMPCO
  • Market Surveillance Panel (received November 18)
 

October 10, 2019

Agenda

Meeting Notes

Meeting to review engagement plan and objectives, draft scope of research and analysis for stakeholder feedback

Required reading material:

  • Utilization Payments Discussion Paper (Dec. 2017)
  • Utilization Payments Discussion Paper (Jan. 2018), presentation to Demand Response Working Group
  •  Utilization Payments (Mar. 2018), presentation to Demand Response Working Group

Other relevant reading material:

  • FERC Order 745
 

September 11, 2019

Stakeholder Feedback

  • AEMA
 

August 22, 2019

Engagement launched – stakeholders to provide feedback on engagement plan (updated October 10, 2019)

  • Communication